Extended Coverage Movie Reviews


MEGADETH - BEST BAND ON PLANET
Megadeth fans, this is a must-have!The story begins with Dave's time with Metallica in the early 80s. James Hetfield, Lars Ulrich, and Ron McGovney are on hand to talk about their experiences together, and the problems that eventually led to Dave's expulsion from the band. Shortly after that, Mustaine hooks up with David Ellefson (the story of how they met is pretty funny), and the rest is the history of one of the greatest bands metal has ever seen.
Anyone even passingly familiar with Megadeth's history will know that Mustaine has fought a constant battle with drug addiction over the years, and that is explored quite a bit here: how their lifestyle of drug abuse affected Dave and his bandmates, how it affected the band as a whole, and how bad the whole situation really got.
There is a lot of interesting commentary given along the way, mostly by Mustaine and Ellefson, but also by several former members of the band, including Al Pitrelli and Jimmy DeGrasso, who were with Megadeth when the band broke up; Marty Friedman, their lead guitarist for ten years; Jeff Young, who was with the band briefly in the late 80s; and Chris Poland, the band's original lead guitarist. Chuck Behler and Nick Menza do not appear, and of course Gar Samuelson passed away some years ago. Alice Cooper even shows up for awhile, talking about his relationship with Dave.
Of course, Megadeth broke up in early 2002, after this documentary was shot, so the injury Dave sustained that stopped him from playing guitar is not covered. As of the time of this writing, Dave is healing up according to the doctors' projections, and so who knows what will happen in the future? Perhaps the mighty Megadeth will rise once again to take their place at the forefront of metal.
This is one of the best "Behind the Music" episodes that VH-1 has done, and the DVD gives us the extended version that we couldn't see on TV. Also included is some extra commentary from many of the people involved, and the video for "Moto Psycho." This is definitely worth the purchase for any Megadeth fan.
BEST BIOGRAPHY EVER!
Of the four commentary tracks, the ones with the greatest general appeal are the one by Jackson and cowriters Fran Walsh and Philippa Boyens, and the one by 10 cast members, but the more technically oriented commentaries by the creative and production staff are also worth hearing. The bonus features (encompassing two complete DVDs) are far superior to the largely promotional materials included on the theatrical release, delving into such matters as script development, casting, and visual effects. The only drawback is that the film is now spread over two discs, with a somewhat abrupt break following the council at Rivendell, due to the storage capacity required for the longer running time, the added DTS ES 6.1 audio, and the commentary tracks. But that's a minor inconvenience. Whether in this collector's gift set (which adds Argonath bookends and a DVD of National Geographic Beyond the Movie: The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring) or the unadorned four-disc set, the extended-edition DVD is the Fellowship DVD to rule them all. --David Horiuchi

Wonderful set!(GIFT SET INFO: This set comes with the movie, plus a set of bookends, and an addition disc with a documentary on the books. The set is beautiful, and the bookends are just wonderful. Spend the extra money and get the gift set!)
Even better than theater release--Extended best choice!The extended DVD(though still not a literal translation of the book) contains many of the moments and subtleties that I so wanted to see in the theater. Though still a compromise relative to the book the additional detail of the extended version adds much more to the story than the extra 20 minutes of footage implies (some additions in places amount to 1/2 to 15 seconds of footage within a scene, yet they contribute much greater depth to the story).
The commentaries provided are fun, fascinating and quite welcome to the acting/filmaking enthusiast. The production-side documentaries and reports are a huge treat--sets, props, costumes, makeup and the insight into everyones dedication show clearly the huge commitment made by the crew and their concern in staying true to the source material as much as possible whilst also translating practically the tale from written word to film faithfully.
There's nothing really wrong with the theater release, but for home viewing even on a small screen the extended version is simply better and more engaging.
I couldn't help but buy the standard version of The Two Towers--tired of waiting--but I have just ordered the extended version of it as based on my experience with FOTR Extd. I know TTT Extended will also be superior to the theater release (and with TTT it ought to be--the editing was a bit choppy).
The extended version is a great value if you want all the extras it provides, and even if you don't, the additional footage is an improvement on the original release and thus worth it.
I LOVE IT!!!!!!!!
While it may seem that there would be nothing left to say after the bevy of features on the extended Fellowship, the four commentary tracks and two discs of supplements on The Two Towers remain informative, fascinating, and funny, far surpassing the recycled materials on the two-disc theatrical version. Highlights of the 6.5 hours' worth of documentaries offer insight on the stunts, the design work, the locations, and the creation of Gollum, and--most intriguing for rabid fans--the film's writers (including Jackson) discuss why they created events that weren't in the book. Providing variety are animatics, rough footage, countless sketches, and a sound-mixing demonstration. Again, the most interesting commentary tracks are by Jackson and writers Fran Walsh and Philippa Boyens and by 16 members of the cast (eight of whom didn't appear in the first film, and even including John Noble, whose Denethor character only appears in this extended cut). The first two installments of Peter Jackson's trilogy have established themselves as the best fantasy films of all time, and among the best film trilogies of all time, and their extended-edition DVD sets have set a new standard for expanding on the already-epic films and providing comprehensive bonus features. --David Horiuchi

Extended Version Just Rightfully Deleted Scenes
Defective Discs 3 & 4???!!!
Amazing Extended Edition of The Lord of the Rings: The Two T
While it may seem that there would be nothing left to say after the bevy of features on the extended Fellowship, the four commentary tracks and two discs of supplements on The Two Towers remain informative, fascinating, and funny, far surpassing the recycled materials on the two-disc theatrical version. Highlights of the 6.5 hours' worth of documentaries offer insight on the stunts, the design work, the locations, and the creation of Gollum, and--most intriguing for rabid fans--the film's writers (including Jackson) discuss why they created events that weren't in the book. Providing variety are animatics, rough footage, countless sketches, and a sound-mixing demonstration. Again, the most interesting commentary tracks are by Jackson and writers Fran Walsh and Philippa Boyens and by 16 members of the cast (eight of whom didn't appear in the first film, and even including John Noble, whose Denethor character only appears in this extended cut). The first two installments of Peter Jackson's trilogy have established themselves as the best fantasy films of all time, and among the best film trilogies of all time, and their extended-edition DVD sets have set a new standard for expanding on the already-epic films and providing comprehensive bonus features. --David Horiuchi

Extended Version Just Rightfully Deleted Scenes
Defective Discs 3 & 4???!!!
Amazing Extended Edition of The Lord of the Rings: The Two T
The extended cut of the finale runs 104 minutes, about 16 longer than when it was broadcast in May 2003. Unlike deleted scenes on movie DVDs, each addition seems like a useful part of the story, and the DVD borrows a helpful feature from the Lord of the Rings extended editions by designating on the chapter menu which scenes are new or extended. Some differences are minor, but there are significant new scenes with Joey at work, Joey and her boyfriend (Jeremy Sisto of Six Feet Under), Joey and Dawson's reunion in Capeside, and Pacey's conversation with old flame Andie (Meredith Monroe).
As they did for two episodes of Dawson's Creek: The Complete First Season, creator Kevin Williamson (who co-wrote the finale) and executive producer Paul Stubin provide a commentary track in which they discuss the new scenes and which characters were originally intended to end up together. There are also four scenes that were filmed for the original pilot presentation (not the finished pilot shown in season one) then reshot. There's a small but important difference in the last scene, Pacey meets Tamara Jacobs in a different video store, and Dawson's dad is played by a different actor before the role was recast with John Wesley Shipp. --David Horiuchi

Worst ending for the best showTHen trhe Jack and Doug story. The first time I`ve heard about it, I coulnd`t believe it. I had to laugh...
The triangel. Well I thought that we were beyond this after S4. It wasn`t a good idea to bring it back.
Pacey and Joey. At the end these 2 sitting on a couch. How romantic. They have cemesty like wet fish. No sparks. Nothing at all.
Dawson. Well he ended up alone. Tradedy. The boy who always believed in love and romance ended up alone. "MArried" to his work,
I was a huge fan of the show since episode 1. So the only logical ending would have been with Dawson and Joey. Two lovers who find their way back to each other. Love can conquer.
Did you remember S1 and S2? Because the finale deneid these 2 season and the love of Dawson and Joey completly. It's a shame.
Well I got this DVD to my birthday. The cutted scenes were much better than the ones we`ve actually seen on tv.
Andie...it was so good to see her again. She and Pacey had mayby the best love story ever on Dawson`s Creek. They had so much chemistry together...I don`t understand why she would be the conclusion prize for Pacey. For me the meeting with Spielberg and Dawson is a conclusion prize for him. He ended alone so why didn`t we let him Spielberg. That`s crap. So the main charater of the show got screwed. He is the only looser of the show (and mayby Jen). But the writers and network were too much for Pacey, the "underdog" (which he nver really was).
So if you are a fan of the true Dawson`s Creec of S1 and S2 you don`t need this DVD. Save the money. If you are a D/J fan, don`t buy it. But if you like the show since S3 or if you are a P/J you`ll love it...
Now one word to Mr. Williamson:
I was happy to read that you`re gonna write the finale. Not because of D/J but because of the real Dawson`s Creek feeling of S1 and S2. But you screwed it.
So I "love" you and I say thank you for creating Dawson`s Creek and giving us S1 and S2. But I "hate" you for the ending of the show.
Put the DC Finale on Your Must Buy List !!It certainly makes up in quality for the disappointing last two seasons of the show, and puts the characters all back in that place we found them, the fictional seaside town of Capeside, MA.
Although I personally could have done without the tragic melodrama, I thought this was a perfect series ender because of one important reason: they finally got it right.
I don't think anyone who has watched these characters over the years and has become invested in their stories can help but feel cheated in how they were treated in the show's final two seasons. But all wrongs seem to be righted here and we are treated to wonderful moments between the core group of Jack, Jen, Dawson, Pacey and Joey.
The issue of the Dawson-Pacey-Joey triangle is also wrapped up perfectly, as the Dawson and Joey saga had been played out to a tired, gasping death over the years. All that we really ever saw of these two was how wrong they were for each other and how miserable they made each other. All in the name of soap operatic drama, I know...but they definitely crossed the line into relationship purgatory with this story and it actually would have been depressing should they have chosen to go with that ending.
Pacey and Joey, on the other hand, had an actual romantic love story that we got to see unfold on screen over the span of a couple of seasons, a nice slow burn from from the first spark of secret feelings tentatively explored to falling head-over-heels in love and literally sailing off into the sunset (another reason why the Dawson and Joey ending would have fell flat in comparison). These two characters were simply a delight to watch when they were together and their undeniable chemistry is also highlighted here (and even discussed at length by the show's creator in the commentary, which, by the way, is worth the price of the DVD alone for any fan of the show from the beginning).
There are deleted scenes included that don't really do a lot to add to the plot, but are fun to watch: a nice scene between Pacey and his brother Doug and the return of Andie for a decent good-bye her fans never got. There is also a great montage at the end that didn't air on television that is a wonderful added bonus.
This is a must-buy DVD for any true fan of the show. If you can get past that notion that Joey for some sad and inexplicable reason was supposed to end up romantically with her best friend Dawson, then you will be able to sit back and appreciate it for what it is: a truly, wonderful good-bye present to its fans.
Again, the commentary by Kevin Williamson and Paul Stupin is just terrific and so fun to listen to.
DAWSON'S CREEK - The series finale

Hardly Meassures UpWhat made the American Pie series work is left behind in this mostly mindness, half-baked attempt to rekindle success with forced comedy, stolen skits (thank you Zoolander for inspiring a dance off), and shallow gags that last too long.
This movie proves why Stiffler was a supporting character in the first two movies as his antics--which now include a squeeky laugh with every line and ann extension of his geneder crisis--grow tiresome by the second. Finch swings back and forth from a unemotioned monk to reaction man. Michelle degresses from her development into a real person in the last movie and turns into the bone queen. And Jim obviously had his mind elsewhere, perhaps that this was likely his last movie.
The acting for many is forced at best, which can only be attributed to worst script. Even the most seasoned actors struggled at times. In fact, the script was so bad, it makes one wonder whether the writer never wrote the old characters into the movie or they simply had the good sense to stay out.
In sum, I intend to stick to my old rule of thumb from now on. When a movie has such a short run in the theater, never buy it sight unseen. Rent it first. Had I stuck to this rule to begin with, I'd be out $3 bucks instead of $20.
Ok movie but not as good as the first 2American Pie 2 was a really good follow up
American Wedding WOULD have been a good movie if it wasnt a follow up. It had too much to live up to so it could NEVER reach the heights of especially the first American Pie. BUT it still have its funny moments. It's worth a rent at least but beware that it aint as good as the first two American Pie movies.
funnier than the first two

Hardly Meassures UpWhat made the American Pie series work is left behind in this mostly mindness, half-baked attempt to rekindle success with forced comedy, stolen skits (thank you Zoolander for inspiring a dance off), and shallow gags that last too long.
This movie proves why Stiffler was a supporting character in the first two movies as his antics--which now include a squeeky laugh with every line and ann extension of his geneder crisis--grow tiresome by the second. Finch swings back and forth from a unemotioned monk to reaction man. Michelle degresses from her development into a real person in the last movie and turns into the bone queen. And Jim obviously had his mind elsewhere, perhaps that this was likely his last movie.
The acting for many is forced at best, which can only be attributed to worst script. Even the most seasoned actors struggled at times. In fact, the script was so bad, it makes one wonder whether the writer never wrote the old characters into the movie or they simply had the good sense to stay out.
In sum, I intend to stick to my old rule of thumb from now on. When a movie has such a short run in the theater, never buy it sight unseen. Rent it first. Had I stuck to this rule to begin with, I'd be out $3 bucks instead of $20.
Ok movie but not as good as the first 2American Pie 2 was a really good follow up
American Wedding WOULD have been a good movie if it wasnt a follow up. It had too much to live up to so it could NEVER reach the heights of especially the first American Pie. BUT it still have its funny moments. It's worth a rent at least but beware that it aint as good as the first two American Pie movies.
funnier than the first two

Typical action flick placed in medieval times
Rob from the movie viewers
More realistic and fantastic than previous Robin HoodsAs for the acting, I find it pretty accurate for the roles portrayed --poor, ignorent farmers-- they aren't supposed to sound like they've just graduated magna cum laude from Oxford. Costner does wonderfully as the hero as does the rest of the cast, and Alan Rickman is marvelous as the Sheriff of Nottingham.
And the stuff about Costner's accent (or lack thereof), come on, if that detracted too much from the movie, you watch movies too seriously! The lack of any good authentic accents doesn't add to the continuity or the mythos as a whole, but for this movie, accents don't detract horribly from it.
For those who compare this to the Earl Flynn version (think coloful Peter Pan) reffer to the paragraph about "homoeroticism."
Overall, Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves isn't the most Oscar Worthy movie of the 90's but it certainly isn't the worst either, and in fact is more fun than most; it definitely is worth your attention and ffits well in the modern day too. I personally love this movie, however, it deservers 4.5 stars instead of the full 5 just based on the fact that Kevin Costner appears naked briefly.


Not what I expected
Of the four commentary tracks, the ones with the greatest general appeal are the one by Jackson and cowriters Fran Walsh and Philippa Boyens, and the one by 10 cast members, but the more technically oriented commentaries by the creative and production staff are also worth hearing. The bonus features (encompassing two complete DVDs) are far superior to the largely promotional materials included on the theatrical release, delving into such matters as script development, casting, and visual effects. The only drawback is that the film is now spread over two discs, with a somewhat abrupt break following the council at Rivendell, due to the storage capacity required for the longer running time, the added DTS ES 6.1 audio, and the commentary tracks. But that's a minor inconvenience. Whether in this four-disc set or in the collector's gift set (which adds Argonath bookends and a DVD of National Geographic Beyond the Movie: The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring), the extended-edition DVD is the Fellowship DVD to rule them all. --David Horiuchi