Medical Views Movie Reviews

The film's lasting achievement is its interweaving of the two distinct threads of western history--the triumph of westward expansion from the urban areas of the East, and the tragic dispossession of the Native Americans who had populated North America for thousands of years. Where previous historical perspectives tended to emphasize one direction or the other, The West (written by Geoffrey C. Ward and Dayton Duncan) achieves a delicate balance, illustrating how nearly every story of pioneering idealism was countered by incidents of tragic loss and suffering.
Brilliantly narrated by Peter Coyote, the series gains further depth and authority through interviews with more than 75 historians and experts. Foremost among them is N. Scott Momaday, scholar, historian, and Kiowa Indian, whose contribution to the series is deeply affecting. Other experts include historians Richard White, Patricia Nelson Limerick, and Stephen Ambrose; writers Michael Dorris and Maxine Hong Kingston; Lakota descendant Charlotte Black Elk; former Texas governor Ann Richards; and many others. When viewed in its entirety, this outstanding, truly epic documentary combines all of its separate episodes to form an emotionally involving narrative of astonishing depth and unprecedented accuracy. To say that The West is essential viewing would be an understatement; this film should be considered mandatory to any balanced awareness of America's turbulent and glorious westward movement. --Jeff Shannon

"someone finally got it right ~ The West!"
PBS; The Best DVD production around....
5 stars is not enough!

An Excellent Family Movie!!

a powerful performance by James Dean
a challenge to the mythFor those who've read the novel, the epic characters from the novel become more realistic in the film; notably Kate, who, in the novel is the personification of evil, in the film is a vital, independent woman motivated and acting by reason, as best as she is allowed by social circumstance. I suppose that, with Kazan's directions, Paul Osborn, the scriptwriter, helped to formulate this almost new character more distinctly, by the dialogues. The same is true for all the characters; in the novel the story is an elaboration on the biblical myth of Cain and Abel, and the heroes evolve as pure and massive spiritual forces incarnate; in the film the heroes are more like real people, of virtue and failure.
This allows a most charming youth, as James Dean then, to masterly implement his role with real empathy, as an (unappreciated by his good -yet- insensitive father) adolescent with a wealth of love, filial loyalty and affection, who can also be dangerous when wounded. He really reverses the tables, and becomes the charmer instead of his brother, the gifted with innocence and father- beloved first borne...
It was the Fifties, the world had come out of a most homicidal war, which had let women in the production process, in the place of the conscripts, new social strata had come out with wealth and a better position; the demand for change was aired by the popular art production most eloquently, too. It spelled challenge to the eternality of old arrangements, social or "mythical', including the concepts of good and evil and the estate of womanhood.
Drastically yet artfully, a question to the truths of the myth is put forth in and with this classic film, that helped to create new popular images as well as to popularise new ideas.
Extraordinary MomentsThe second takes place on the ferris wheel ride. As Dean kisses Julie Harris, the fingers of his hand slowly stretch to a blossom born of stunned discovery.
Astonishing.

One section that may sit poorly with modern audiences features Nancy and Julia discussing how to emphasize one's femininity at the expense of hiding the real you--an indication of how much American thinking has changed in a relatively short period of time. Nevertheless, this is a charming tale featuring toe-tapping ragtime music, wonderful songs by Richard M. Sherman and Robert B. Sherman including "Summer Magic" and "The Ugly Bug Ball," and the incomparable talents of Mills and Ives. Take a trip down memory lane and don't forget the kids. (Ages 7 and older) --Tami Horiuchi

Somewhat disappointedWell, about two weeks ago, I came across "Summer Magic" at the public library, and snatched it to my bosom to take home and show the folks. But alas, the 90 minutes or so preceding that last 15 minutes were not so engaging as I had hoped.
"Summer Magic" is not a bad movie, but it is really rather uneventful. Burl Ives just shuffles around his store and Dorothy McGuire's house. We are told at the outset that Ms. McGuire has been recently widowed and left kinda penniless. But when she comes home, she's pretty stylishly dressed for a grieving widow and never seems to rgeret the loss of whoever it was she was married to. I wondered if this was so she could find romance in the new location she was headed for with her family; she'd have to be out of mourning almost to think of such things. But no, nothing like that developed. Her daughter Hayley Mills was the usual HM kind of heroine, except that I did find her a little too cruel to her visiting cousin. I don't know why that girl would elect to keep living there, because nobody does treat her nicely, despite what Ms. McGuire says. Hayley's brothers are weird looking, so much so that I found Burl's son Michael J. Pollard to be better-looking than they, so draw what conclusions you will from that.
So, my quest for "Summer Magic" was an anticlimax for me. Workmanlike Disney fare. Mediocre.
One of the few Hayley Mills Movies I can stand
great family movie
Mostel is Max Bialystock, a gone-to-seed Broadway producer who spends his days wheedling checks from his "investors," elderly women for whom Bialystock is only too willing to provide company. When wide-eyed auditor Leo Bloom (Wilder) comes to check the books, he unwittingly inspires the wild-eyed Max to hatch a sure-fire plan: sell 25,000 percent of his next show, produce a deliberate flop, then abscond with the proceeds. Unfortunately for the producers (but fortunately for us), their candidate for failure is Springtime for Hitler, a Brooksian conceit that envisions what Goebbels might have accomplished with a little help from Busby Berkeley.
Truly startling during its original 1968 release, The Producers does show signs of age in some peripheral scenes that make merry at the expense of gays and women. But the show's nifty cast (notably including the late Dick Shawn as LSD, the space cadet that snags the musical's title role, and Kenneth Mars as the helmeted playwright) clicks throughout, and the sight of Mostel fleecing his marks is irresistibly funny. Add Wilder's literally hysterical Bloom, and it's easy to understand the film's exalted status among late-'60s comedies. --Sam Sutherland

DisappointingOf course lots of people really like this movie. I recommend renting it or catching it on cable before buying the video.
Funny and belly-aching...
You will laugh so hard that you'll soil yourself!!!
Mostel is Max Bialystock, a gone-to-seed Broadway producer who spends his days wheedling checks from his "investors," elderly women for whom Bialystock is only too willing to provide company. When wide-eyed auditor Leo Bloom (Wilder) comes to check the books, he unwittingly inspires the wild-eyed Max to hatch a sure-fire plan: sell 25,000 percent of his next show, produce a deliberate flop, then abscond with the proceeds. Unfortunately for the producers (but fortunately for us), their candidate for failure is Springtime for Hitler, a Brooksian conceit that envisions what Goebbels might have accomplished with a little help from Busby Berkeley.
Truly startling during its original 1968 release, The Producers does show signs of age in some peripheral scenes that make merry at the expense of gays and women. But the show's nifty cast (notably including the late Dick Shawn as LSD, the space cadet that snags the musical's title role, and Kenneth Mars as the helmeted playwright) clicks throughout, and the sight of Mostel fleecing his marks is irresistibly funny. Add Wilder's literally hysterical Bloom, and it's easy to understand the film's exalted status among late-'60s comedies. --Sam Sutherland

DisappointingOf course lots of people really like this movie. I recommend renting it or catching it on cable before buying the video.
Funny and belly-aching...
You will laugh so hard that you'll soil yourself!!!

I always enjoyed this as a Kid
A Christmas Classic for the whole family!This charming show will remind us all that each and every one of us has a purpose and that all of God's creations great and small deserve love, kindness and a moment to shine, like Rudolph and his wonderful nose.
Enjoy and have a Beautiful CHRISTmas!
classic

I always enjoyed this as a Kid
A Christmas Classic for the whole family!This charming show will remind us all that each and every one of us has a purpose and that all of God's creations great and small deserve love, kindness and a moment to shine, like Rudolph and his wonderful nose.
Enjoy and have a Beautiful CHRISTmas!
classic

Classic
Only rarely the t'wain shall meet....For me, one of the most memorable scenes occurs when, just before dawn, McKay and Leech finally have it out. It is an awkward but inevitable and immensely effective fist fight, with much of it filmed as if we were observing it at a distance. Of course, the fist fight achieves nothing other than demonstrating that McKay is more of a "man" than Leech once thought. Before they begin throwing punches, McKay insists that no one know about their fight. Leech totally misunderstands McKay's reasons. Another memorable sequence of events focuses on Terrill and Hannassey as they slowly and carefully work their way through a canyon to their final confrontation. To repeat, theirs is a zero sum game except that neither wins. In these and other scenes, Planer's cinematography and Jerome Moross' music score blend effectively with the cast's superb performances under Wyler's direction.
Why has The Big Country been under appreciated, if not totally ignored among western films? I have no idea. I really don't.
A few commentsIt's interesting to contrast the quiet and unassuming confidence Peck projects in his character with the characters of the westerners, who assume Peck's low-key personality means he's a coward, or at least unwilling to defend himself, despite the fact that he's a former sea captain and has probably seen more danger on the high seas in a few years of sailing than most of the ranchers have seen in their entire lives. His manhood is constantly being questioned by the cowboy types, who don't understand Peck's more restrained nature nor his background.
For example, in one scene he rides off into the desert overnight to visit a neighbor and doesn't come back the next day. They mount a search party, thinking he's lost, but he's not. He has a map and a compass, and he knows how to use them. Eventually he rides into the camp of the searchers, who haven't been able to find him yet, apparently none the worse for wear, but the ranch foreman accuses him of lying when Peck says he wasn't lost. The ignorant cowboys have no idea that a former sea captain like Peck, who could navigate a ship over thousands of miles of open sea with no landmarks with a sextent and a chronograph, would find it easy to navigate on land with a map and a compass. But the ranchers remain unconvinced.
There are several other incidents like this, and even his new wife doubts him. In the end, however, Peck shows himself to be twice the man of any of the other brash and blustery cowboy types who have doubted him all along when he single-handedly confronts Burl Ives and his gang alone at the end of the movie. He also realizes that his wife, who also doubted him, isn't worth the trouble and isn't the girl for him. Instead, he ends up with the Jean Simmons, who understood him better all along (and who tried to talk sense into his wife, unsuccessfully), and who is a much classier lady, anyway.
I have to agree with the other reviewers and say that Burl Ives is the real standout and surprise here, turning in a great performance as the crusty, scheming old patriarch of a disreputable family of ne'er-do-wells and ruffians who feels he deserves better, including his errant son, played by Chuck Connors, who also turns in a fine performance. It's too bad Connors didn't get that many other good roles like this, as he shows he's a much more capable actor than he's normally given credit for. The entire cast does a great job, actually, and Charlton Heston is also good in his role as Peck's nemesis, playing something of a bad guy with regard to Peck, but who eventually comes to appreciate Peck isn't the man he thought he was when he and Peck get into a fist fight. Both men end up taking and dishing out a lot of punishment during the course of the long fight, so there isn't exactly a clear winner, but Peck shows he can certainly take care of himself and isn't the pushover Heston had thought.
The movie also has a great score that really adds to the ambience and drama, which helps, since the movie is over 2 hours and 40 minutes long. Overall, it's a fine movie and a great western that isn't as well known as it should be. Big Steve says go rent it and don't Bogart the popcorn.

James Goldman won an Oscar® for the brilliant screenplay, based on his Broadway play. It is a tad wordy, as the action is kept to a minimum, but those words are sharp as daggers. The humor is wicked and black and delivered with very dry, dead-on precision. Sparks fly and the screen sizzles whenever Hepburn and O'Toole tango, which is often. Both were nominated for Academy Awards® for their vigorous performances. (She won; he didn't.) There's also an infamous homo-erotic exchange between Philip of France (Timothy Dalton) and Richard the Lionhearted (Anthony Hopkins). Both actors were making their feature-film debuts. --Rochelle O'Gorman

"We could tangle spiders in the webs you weave."King Henry II of Britain (O'Toole) comes to the realization that he must finally decide which of his sons will succeed him as King. He is leaning towards naming John (Nigel Terry) as his heir to the throne, but his estranged wife, Eleanor of Aquitaine (Hepburn) favors Richard (Anthony Hopkins) instead. Further complicating the situation is the scheming of the son left out of the equation, Geoffrey (John Castle) and the arrival in Britain of King Philip of France (Timothy Dalton) who was promised the hand of Henry's sister, Alais (Jane Merrow) in marriage. As all the players jockey for position amongst each other, Henry tries to stay one step ahead of them all while dodging venomous barbs from Eleanor.
"The Lion in Winter" is dialogue-dense and not a film for the action-adventure enthusiast. It is a film build around political intrigue and the difficult decisions that determine the destinies of nations. There are no epic swordfights or grand battles between warring armies on open fields. Instead, there are battles of the mind as strategies are formed and countered. The performances are solid throughout but Hepburn must be singled out. She is so regal as Eleanor that one could easily mistake her for a true monarch. If ever there was an actress born to play royalty, it was Hepburn.
Shall we hang the holly, or each other?It is a rare instance of all the right things coming together at the right time - a great script and a great cast. This is definitely one of Katherine Hepburn's best roles even though she made it when she was quite past her prime. Next to Lawrence of Arabia, this is Peter O'Toole's best film. It is also Anthony Hopkins first film. It reads as a textbook as to how a movie should be made. They, quite simply, don't make 'em like this anymore.
The plot concerns a (fictional) Christmas court held in 1183. Henry II takes his wife, Eleanor of Aquitaine, out of prison to help him great the young French king Phillip. Their three sons - John, Geoffrey, and Richard Coeur de Lion - are there as well. What ensues is an exercise in political machinations by the most dysfunctional family you have ever seen in your life. It has inspired me to learn more about the personages actually involved.
A wonderful, enjoyable, and accurate portrayal
Never have I witnessed such openness in the telling of the triumphs and tragedies of America's westward expansion ~ it took more than 75 historians on this project to make it right. Right from the git go we have Episode One(The People/Bonus DVD Features), Episodes Two & Three (Empire Upon The Trails/The Speck of the Future), Episodes Four & Five (Fight No More Forever/The Geography of Hope) and Episodes Eight & Nine (Ghost Dance/One Sky Above Us) ~ featuring some of the most beautiful photography of our country. The entire collection covers the period of 1800 to 1915, wonderfully narated by Peter Coyote (whose voice sounds very much like Henry Fonda).
This is one of, if not the best documentaries on "The West", I've ever seen. Been collecting Time/Life leatherbound books on the subject for years ~ Frederic Remington and Charles M. Russell books and paintings ~ plus bronze of "The Mountain Man", "The Rattlesnake" and "Comin' Through the Rye" by Frederic Remington. Ken Burns "The West" on DVD is something I will cherish the rest of my life ~ will pass it on to my children and grandchildren, so they will know this is the way it was moving WEST!
Total Time: 12 Hours ~ PBS B8891 ~ (9/30/2003)